John Kosner Spoke with Robert O’Connell of The Wall Street Journal about The NBA’s In-Season Tournament

Original Article: Wall Street Journal, by Robert O’Connell, November 2nd, 2023

The NBA Created Another Championship. Is It a Gimmick or Genius?

There’s a new import to the NBA, and this one, unlike Victor Wembanyama, doesn’t block shots or dunk alley-oops. The inaugural “In-Season Tournament,” which will unfold over the first quarter of the league’s calendar, is a novelty among major U.S. team sports. But it borrows from the way the rest of the world has long done the business of competition.

“Whether it’s international soccer, international basketball, individual sports here in the U. S.—golf, tennis, racing, fighting—the idea that you can raise multiple trophies within a calendar season is incredibly common, and appreciated by fans,” said Evan Wasch, the NBA’s executive vice president of basketball strategy and analytics.

“There’s an untapped opportunity here,” Wasch said, “a chance to be a pioneer.”

The experiment begins on Friday night. Seven matchups will raise the curtain on the tournament, which will end with a trophy—the NBA Cup—lifted in Las Vegas on Dec. 9. The league’s objective is to enliven an early stretch of its season, to boost ratings and amplify chatter, to grab up a greater share of the sizable audience for live sports.

But the question is: how much will anybody—players and fans, advertisers and prospective media-rights partners—care about a competition manufactured out of thin air?

“We’re looking to create a new tradition here, and as the saying goes, new traditions aren’t created overnight,” commissioner Adam Silver said in September. “It will be the fans and the coverage,” he added, “which will be telling us whether this is working or not.”

This bid for attention comes at a moment when the NBA’s ability to attract eyeballs holds particular significance. The league is negotiating new mediarights deals, which will go into effect after the 2024-25 season. Current partners ESPN and TNT are in renewal talks but aren’t looking to significantly increase the estimated combined $2.6 billion they spend to broadcast NBA games, and streaming providers Apple and Amazon are interested in taking on packages of games.

The specifics of the tournament have more in common with soccer’s World Cup and college basketball’s March Madness than with the NBA playoff format that decides the championship each June. The league’s 30 teams have been sorted into six groups, and the winner of each group—plus two wild-card entrants—will land in a eight-team, single-elimination bracket. The semifinals (airing on ESPN and TNT) and final (airing on ABC) will take place at Las Vegas’ T-Mobile Arena. Schedule maneuvering will let every game but the final swap in for a regular season slot; only the two teams competing for the trophy will play an extra contest past the usual 82.

The league and its partners hope that the single-elimination model will bring enough of a spark to convince two crucial groups—fans and players—to buy in. Most NBA players haven’t appeared in a string of winner-take-all games since their collegiate days; the setup could bring NCAA Tournament-esque chaos and one-night-only star turns that run counter to the more predictable best-of-seven playoff model.

“Seasons are long,” Craig Barry, executive vice president and chief content officer at TNT Sports, said. “Creating a little bit of excitement, finding ways to eventize regular season games and get fans excited is important.”

A successful In-Season Tournament could demonstrate that the NBA isn’t merely a bankable property—a rare, reliable deliverer of live audiences to advertisers—but also an evolving one, willing to break with tradition in pursuit of growth. Wasch and Silver have both acknowledged that some fans feel the league’s regular season has lost some of its intrigue, with teams regularly resting players to keep them healthy for the playoffs. In 2021, the NBA debuted its play-in tournament, a competition for the playoffs’ final spots that has energized the sometimes drowsy period just before the postseason.

“In the current environment,” said John Kosner, a consultant and former ESPN executive, “if you’re not constantly improving your offerings for fans, TV networks, sponsors and advertisers, you’re falling behind.”

Still, the new event has been met by a mix of curiosity and skepticism from basketball fans. Many observers online have cracked jokes about the garish, striped courts teams will lay down for tournament games. Some have also noted that the In-Season Tournament doesn’t quite meet the standard of the contests it takes inspiration from.

In European soccer, the Champions League brings together top teams from across top domestic competitions: the English Premier League, Spain’s La Liga, Germany’s Bundesliga and more. Tennis players and golfers compete across surfaces that have much more substantial variations that paint color.

“The reason people like the Champions League is because we get to see Real Madrid against Manchester City, which doesn’t happen all that often,” Tobias Moskowitz, a Yale professor who teaches sports analytics, said. “We’re not getting that in the NBA, right? It’s more, maybe the Bucks end up playing the Suns one more time than we thought.”

The NBA will incentivize its athletes with a monetary reward—the winning team will receive $500,000 per player—and, Wasch said, the possibility of legacy-boosting achievements: All-Tournament team nods and MVPs, the trophy itself. “If we’re seeing early indications of success, you’re going to see a little ratcheted-up intensity than you see during a typical regular-season game,” Silver said.

The league’s current network partners likewise hope that adjustments to their presentations, such as never-before-seen camera angles, bring viewers into the fold. “Differentiation is always of interest to fans,” said David Roberts, ESPN’s head of event and studio production.

Executives at both ESPN and TNT said that the ongoing negotiations around the next media-right deals—and the possibility that the tournament their networks help produce and publicize will fall in the hands of a streamer in a couple seasons—haven’t affected the enthusiasm with which they have worked on the project.

“It’s inevitable that there’s potentially going to be more platforms and companies interested,” Barry said. “That’s a good thing, because that means it’s healthy.”

Silver has emphasized taking the long view of the In-Season Tournament, noting that format changes could come in future iterations. Cachet is impossible to fasttrack. Time will tell whether players’ investment brings about Wasch’s vision of a competition that “comes close” to the traditional playoffs, or whether they treat tournament games as normal contests on flashier floors.

“It will take an identity of its own over time,” Golden State Warriors superstar Stephen Curry said over the summer. “It’s hard to kind of predict what it’s going to feel like or look like from a fan perspective, a player perspective…It’s still 82 games, it’s just under a different narrative.”